Rome Travel Guide

Rome Architecture, History, Art, Museums, Galleries, Fashion, Music, Photos, Walking and Hiking Itineraries, Neighborhoods, News and Social Commentary, Politics, Things to Do in Rome and Environs. Over 900 posts

Showing posts with label dry fresco. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dry fresco. Show all posts

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Pontormo and the Origins of Modernism

 

We very much enjoyed the enormous Pontormo show at the Scuderie del Quirinale, but it took some doing. Florentine mannerists are not our first choice for entertaining art, and paintings of Mary and the baby Jesus, of which there are many in the exhibit--especially the first half--are not endlessly fascinating to us. Other folks must feel the same, because timed tickets the first few days of the exhibit were easy to get, and there were only a few other visitors. Like others we talked to about the show, we had for a time thought his name was Pontorno. It just sounded better.

Jacopo Carucci (Pontormo, 1494-1557) was a mannerist painter from the Florentine School, a student of Andrea del Sarto. 

Bill got involved at first by looking at content, doing a quick study of Mary's relationship to her baby. He discovered that most of the time, her gaze was elsewhere. Other characters, too, seemed distracted, looking here and there, into the near and far distance, rather than focusing on the Christ-child, there to offer us eternal life, as part of a deal ("whosoever believeth in me shall never die," as I learned as a Catechism-studying 13-year-old Lutheran). The lead photo above and a couple below here are examples:




Then we began to wonder WHY Mary was depicted as distracted--that is, concerned about something other than her baby. Maybe, we speculated, the painters--including Pontormo--were also distracted, in the sense of caring less about the religious content they were painting, than about how they were painting it.

Remarkably, the exhibition text notes for the show had some confirmation for this theory, noting that some of the figures--particularly in later work in the show--were elongated or twisted or compressed, emphasizing geometry rather than the biblical or historical event being depicted. Pontormo used color, too, as an expressive device, and he played with space and form in unusual ways. That observation is aided in part by a series of works by the Mannerist painter that were done with "dry fresco," which does not preserve well. Paint chips and flakes from the surface. The result leads one to look at the paintings differently. Here are some examples, portions of Pontormo paintings, that in color and form have a decidedly modernist tone:


This jaunty figure, carrying what appears to be a tray, is at the top of "Christ Before Pontius Pilate." It has the feel of 19th-century realism:


The show concludes with "The Visitation" (1528-29), arguably Pontormo's most famous work. It features the encounter of two pregnant women--Mary and Elizabeth--and includes two other women, possibly ladies-in-waiting. The contemporary fame of Pontormo's painting owes much to a 1995 video, "The Greeting," by Bill Viola, showing the Mary/Elizabeth encounter in a 10-minute slow motion sequence. We saw it years ago at Buffalo's Albright Knox Gallery (now the AKG Buffalo) and were mesmerized. (Viola's piece is in Rome contemporaneously with the Pontormo show, but it's inside the Forum, and so to see it one must buy a ticket to the Forum and locate it within that vast space.)

Mary has learned that she will conceive the Son of God. She has also learned that her older cousin, Elizabeth, formerly barren, is 6 months pregnant (with John the Baptist, it will turn out), and she has traveled to visit her.  

Although the curation notes present Pontormo's "The Visitation" as the greatest thing since sliced bread (or before sliced bread), it had for us a strange vibe. 

Yes, the two women are pleased to see each other. The other two women look past Mary and Elizabeth with blank expressions. 

Both protagonists are, let's say, hefty, perhaps reflecting their conditions. What's dominant in the painting, however, are the gowns: pink, blue, green and orange. At the center of the piece are the blue folds of Mary's dress, as if the artist was more concerned with rendering those contours than anything having to do with the sacred.

It's the early 16th century, but one can see the fabric fraying--the religious fabric, that is--and something else (one could call it modernism) emerging. 

The show opened October 9 and closes February 7, 2027. 

Bill 




T